Anthologies - The Art of Compilation

I was delighted to see that the program for this year's Eastercon included a panel discussion on creating anthologies. The Panel featured Ian Whates: author, anthologist and founder of New Con Press; Ellen Datlow: American professional anthologist; Colin Harvey and Gary Couzens: writers and occassional anthologists.

There were a lot of discussions about submissions, pros and cons of open vs. invited vs. reprint (open is the most work, reprint is really fun and invited is often frustrating). It was interesting to hear that, even for anthologies, the big six publishers have a heirarchy of authors such that for every 'A' list author, you might need 2-3 B-list authors. The publishers also require 1/3 more invites than desired for publication due to the estimated number who won't end up producing a story.

It was also interesting to learn that anthologies are much more common and accepted in the US than they are in the UK. Apparently, it's very rare in the UK for a big publisher to accept a pitch for an anthology regardless of the idea. They just don't want to produce them and most British anthologies are done by small presses. This suggests to me that I should target the US market much more for selling.

Most positive for me, in this discussion, was when it came around to the layout. The two most experienced anthologists confirmed my own thoughts on layout, and the way I approached the layout for Assassins' Canon. i.e. generally the first and last are the strongest, with the longer, more challenging reads in the middle. With the added idea that the first story having the added ideas that it should set the expectations for the anthology, without being too heavy.

For Assassins' Canon, there were a number of stories I could have started with, but in the end I chose Ken Goldman's 'Fat Larry's Night with the Alligators' because it emboidied all the ideas above and, I felt, led nicely into the many directions and types of stories the anthology included. Likewise, Jason Frank's 'XDA Zai: The Wild Hunt' was a strong story that wrapped up the anthology in the same way--a nice mix of real and surreal. That said, there's not a single story I'm unhappy about including and I remain thrilled at the finished product. I can only hope future anthologies from Utililty Fog Press will be as good.